2021 BMW R 18 First Edition | Road Test Review

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
The new R 18 is the first salvo in BMW’s Heritage cruiser family, which is likely to include a bagger and perhaps even a touring bike in the future. Seen here in First Edition garb that includes lots of chrome, paint and functional options, it’s BMW’s second attempt to gain some traction in America’s large cruiser market, following the R1200C of 1998-2004. (Photos by Kevin Wing)

Some motorcycle manufacturers have a difficult time accepting that Harley-Davidson’s 55-60% share of the cruiser motorcycle market in the U.S. is as much a result of cultural preference as it is affection for traditionally styled bikes. Americans love their cruisers and baggers, but these days mostly want them Made in the USA. Despite an exceptionally good run, the Japanese have pretty much thrown in the towel — with a couple exceptions there hasn’t been a new Japanese cruiser or bagger in a decade. As long as they’re selling lots of ADV, sport and sport-touring bikes, Germany and Italy haven’t paid much attention to our cruiser market, either. But every so often someone on the continent decides that they need a bigger chunk of the American motorcycle market, and out pops a Euro cruiser that either misses the styling dartboard completely or has an unacceptable engine layout. Or both.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
With 788 pounds and a 68.1-inch wheelbase to throw around, the R 18’s minimal cornering clearance isn’t really an issue. Just don’t go there.

BMW’s first attempt was with the R1200C, unveiled to gasps for the 1998 model year. Limited to the existing boxer engine and techy running gear like the Telelever front end and single-sided Monolever swingarm, the result was a nice enough motorcycle in terms of handling and features. But the opposed twin was too small and underpowered to compete in the seismic V-twin market, the ergonomics were weird, and the styling too, er, unconventional. Auf wiedersehn — its last model year was 2004.

This time might be different.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
You would think that Big Boxer would put out a lot of heat, but we never noticed any, even in 85-degree weather.

RELATED: 2022 BMW R 18 B and R 18 Transcontinental | First Look Review

In creating the new R 18, to its credit once again BMW did not build a Harley clone, going so far as to boldly stamp the bike with the words, “Berlin Built.” The R 18 still uses a boxer engine instead of a V-twin, and this go-round BMW is fully committed to its iconic powerplant, taking care to highlight the advantages of a mid-mount footpeg position (active, upright seating, etc.) necessitated by the engine’s flat opposed cylinders versus feet forward. And BMW recognized that this time the engine needed to be big — really BIG. So the pair of 4.2-inch slugs and 100mm stroke in the Big Boxer give it a displacement of 1,802cc, or 110ci, which compares well with Harley’s 108s and Indian’s 111s.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
BMW nailed the styling on the R 18, and with a few refinements to the suspension and seat, it can be a really nice bike to ride, too.

To make it look right, BMW’s styling team stepped back into the company’s motorcycling history, taking cues from the 1930’s R5. “We took a deep look at our own museum, and we condensed these icons from the past, and found five super-important things that you will find all of on this bike,” said Edgar Heinrich, BMW’s head of motorcycle design. In fact it’s easy to see the R5 reflected in the R 18’s double-loop frame and swingarm that give it a modern hardtail cruiser look, as well as the teardrop 4.2-gallon fuel tank, exposed final drive shaft, metal fork shrouds, fishtail dual exhaust and pinstriped black paint on the R 18 First Edition. All of this is pleasingly mashed together with contemporary cruiser licks like bobbed fenders, a semi-slammed rear end and fat tube-type wheels and tires to create the first cruiser in BMW’s Heritage family. We’re told it’s not the last.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
BMW’s largest engine to date has four overhead valves per cylinder actuated by a pair of dual rocker arms with screw-and-locknut adjusters, pushrods and one camshaft per side, parallel to and above the crankshaft.

At 788 pounds fully fueled sitting on a long 68.1-inch wheelbase, the R 18 looks and feels overbuilt, like there’s a roomful of bagger and dresser bodywork tucked away somewhere just waiting to be hung on the sturdy platform. As befits a premium cruiser, BMW styled the R 18 mostly in metal — the engine and gearbox only account for 244 pounds, so we’re talking a whopping 520-pound rolling chassis minus the Big Boxer and a few options. Some parts like the wheels and levers are aluminum, but you’ll find very little plastic, and the tank, fenders, side covers, headlight, instrument and fork covers are all steel.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
Seating is typical wide-bar cruiser, except for the mid-mount footpegs necessitated by those big jugs.

A little weight is attributable to the extra features on this First Edition (included in optional packages), such as the swath of chrome, heated grips, an alarm system, Reverse Assist (flip a lever, hit the starter button, backward you go) and Adaptive Headlight that illuminates the inside of corners. Electronic wizardry was kept to a minimum, though—riders overwhelmingly told BMW that this bike should not be a rolling computer. It still has Integral ABS of course, in which the front lever actuates both the strong front and rear ABS brakes, and the pedal just the rear. Switchable ASC or traction control, Motor Slip Reduction (MSR), a slipper clutch and Hill Start Control (eases starting out on inclines) are all onboard, and the R 18 has three playful ride modes, Rock, Roll and Rain. In addition to turning the volume up or down on the throttle response, changing modes alters the amount of ASC intervention, and even tweaks the idle. In Roll and Rain, it’s pretty tame, but in Rock at a stop, those howitzer-sized pistons waggle the handlebar and shimmy shimmy ko ko bop shake the bike side-to-side like a vibrating bed. Yet unlike a lot of fuel-injected bikes in the equivalent “sport” mode, throttle response is smooth and linear in Rock without abruptness, and comparatively boring in the other modes.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
All LED dual headlight is available with cornering lights.

The R 18 wants to Rock right from startup, too. Quite often those big cylinders light off with a Womp!, and the engine rocks the bike strongly side-to-side — enough that it can yank the grips from your hands if you’re not ready for it. Eventually it settles into a nice loping idle, but when you twist the throttle in neutral or at lower speeds you can also feel the torque reaction of the longitudinal crankshaft rotate the bike slightly on its axis, like BMW boxers of yore. On the Jett Tuning dyno the Big Boxer set a new record for boxer torque at the rear wheel, with 109.2 lb-ft at 2,900 rpm, and 80.3 horsepower at 4,500 rpm. At speed the R 18 feels a lot like most big twins, with loads of torque right from idle that drops off quickly past 4,000 rpm. Redline is way up at 5,750 rpm, but you’ll spend far more time in the rev basement on this bike, short-shifting and enjoying the somewhat muted bark from its two fishtails. Especially since the seat and grips vibrate rather badly at anything above 3,000-3,200 rpm….

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Dyno Test

Perched with arms outstretched to the wide bar and feet comfortably on the mid-mount footpegs, the R 18’s seating position helps you fight the wind at speed, and at just 27.2 inches high the seat is an easy reach to the ground. Since there’s so little cornering clearance, footpegs drag early in corners, and the crankshaft torque reaction doesn’t really have a chance to detract from the bike’s handling. Which is about as good as you’d expect from such a big bike—slow and stable in corners and on the highway, heavy and ponderous at a walking pace or parking (thank goodness for that Reverse Assist), though tight U-turns can be mastered with some practice. That wide handlebar really helps maneuver the bike, though one grip can end up quite a reach at full lock. Of greater note is the suspension, which only offers spring preload adjustment in the rear and just 4.7/3.5 inches of travel front/rear. That’s not unusually short for a cruiser, and the punishing ride that results is no surprise either. It is eyebrow raising, though, that with all of BMW’s advanced suspension experience it didn’t give its first real cruiser some rear suspension comfortably on par with say, a 2014 Indian Chief. To make matters worse the stock seat is merely a seat-shaped rock — fortunately for anyone who actually wants to ride this bike accessory comfort seats are available.

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
BMW resisted the temptation to put a boss ultra-wide rear tire on the R 18, so it needs less muscle to turn.

BMW has given the R 18 adjustable brake and clutch levers, and a powerful twin LED headlight and LED brake/taillights integrated into the turn signals. The single instrument incorporates an analog speedometer and useful digital display with tachometer, trip computer and more, and there’s a handy electrical accessory socket behind the left cylinder. Pages upon pages of accessories hail the R 18’s arrival — there’s even a Bobber conversion and premium Roland Sands machined parts ready to go, as well as an Apehanger conversion with 21-inch front wheel. Knock yourself out, have fun storming the castle….

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
Spoked wheels necessitate inner tubes. Integral ABS brakes are strong and functional, with perhaps a little more pull at the lever than we like.

Obviously I’m of two minds regarding the R 18. On the one hand, I’m disappointed that the bike isn’t nicer to ride. Harsh rear suspension, minimal cornering clearance and heavy vibration can’t be cured with an accessory seat or chrome dingle balls. On the other, I think it’s a great-looking, badass, real-steel cruiser that rides its own path and makes no apologies for it. It also hides a lot of modern tech in a classic platform. “One of the hardest things to do is to develop a modern bike with a classic look, with no exposed wires, no sensors, no black box visible. It’s one of the biggest achievements for the designers,” said Heinrich. No doubt with the possible exception of the mufflers’ size (and keep in mind that the camera puts on 10 pounds), they nailed it. 

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Review
Parallels between the BMW R5 of the 1930s and the new R 18 (this one a Bobber version) are striking, from the lines of the hardtail-look frame and tank to the exposed driveshaft and fishtail exhaust (OK, if you squint a little…).

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Specs:

Base Price: $17,495
Price as Tested: $22,120 (Special Edition finish, Premium & Select Packages, Passenger Kit)
Warranty: 3 yrs., 36,000 miles
Website: bmwmotorcycles.com

Type: Air/oil-cooled opposed flat twin
Displacement: 1,802cc
Bore x Stroke: 107.1 x 100.0mm
Compression Ratio: 9.6:1
Valve Train: OHV, 4 valves per cyl.
Valve Insp. Interval: 6,000 miles
Fuel Delivery: BMS-O EFI w/ 48mm throttle body
Lubrication System: Wet sump, 4.2-qt cap.
Transmission: 6-speed, hydraulically actuated single-plate dry slipper clutch
Final Drive: Shaft, 3.091:1

Ignition: BMS-O Electronic
Charging Output: 600 watts max
Battery: 12V 26AH

Frame: Tubular-steel double cradle w/ tubular-steel double-sided swingarm
Wheelbase: 68.1 in.
Rake/Trail: 32.7 degrees/5.9 in.
Seat Height: 27.2 in.
Suspension, Front: 49mm telescopic fork w/ 4.7-in. travel
Rear: Single cantilever shock, adj. for spring preload w/ 3.5-in. travel
Brakes, Front: Dual 300mm discs w/ 4-piston opposed calipers
Rear: Single 300mm disc w/ 4-piston opposed caliper
Wheels, Front: Spoked, tube-type, 3.50 x 19 in.
Rear: Spoked, tube-type, 5.0 x 16 in.
Tires, Front: 120/70-BH19
Rear: 180/65-BH16
Wet Weight: 788 lbs. (as tested)
Load Capacity: 447 lbs. (as tested)
GVWR: 1,235 lbs.

Horsepower: 80.3 Horsepower at 4,500 rpm
Torque: 109.2 lb-ft. of torque at 2,900 rpm
Fuel Capacity: 4.2 gals., last 1.0-gal. warning light on
MPG: 91 PON Min (low/avg/high) 30.3/34.2/38.2
Estimated Range: 144 miles
Indicated RPM at 60 MPH: 2,100

2021 BMW R 18 First Edition Photo Gallery:


  1. At ~550 lbs. curb, they have a buyer. At nearly 800 lbs., no thank you. I was so hyped when this series was announced; I didn’t realize they’d use lead alloy for the rolling stock.

    • You meant to say you’re not in the market for a Cruiser right? ; ) But reverse is a option, probably a must for such a heavy bike.

  2. $18k, 144 mile range, terrible cornering capabilities, a “rock” for a seat and a jarring suspension- this is the best that BMW can do after a few years in prototyping, design and testing ? They still can’t get it right.

    • Had a few harleys and rode a super chief but brought a R18 because there cheap and it’s the most enjoyment I’ve ever had no issues with reliability and fuel consumption if you keep your speed down to 75mph is amazing.

  3. I rode one on a Motorrad BMW event. Fisrt impression was great, i really like the design. Then i got to ride it, and i was convinced to keep my old Valkyrie. Sluggish, almost 5 seconds for 0-60. Had to keep in lower gear to get any acceleration. Engine torque is problematic, accelerating in a curve straightened the bike or made it go lower, making me lose my line a couple times. Brakes and clutch actuated by cables, really? Crap seats, handlebars vibrating so much my hands were numb after 10 minutes. Not for me Maybe for the flashy duck walker riding 500 milles a year, certainly not for me

  4. I have an R18 and I find the seat to be very comfortable and turning corners is no problem. I love this bike, especially for long distances.

  5. For what it’s worth, I just saw 4 used ones for sale in NH, each with 4K miles or less. They are beautiful bikes but the stock seat is a plank and the optional seat is better. And after doing some research I was ready to go back and buy one, but the lack of ground clearance dashed that notion.

  6. The benchmarks of the HD Street Bob, Low Rider, Indian Chief Dark Horse are too strong for this effort. I also think it’s beautiful and looks like a bargain on the used market.

    Actually, the used prices might be good enough to just do the trick…

  7. Can’t understand why a short evaluation was done on the r18 when they are a very different beast I brought one and after a short period of very regular rides adjusted to it and love every minute of riding it that’s even after recent major heart surgery.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here